New Interests of the Beatles Means the End of an Era
No Writer Listed
London Sunday Times
November 16, 1966
There was no formal announcement, no fuss, nor, for that matter, any great astonishment at the news that the Beatles' phenomenon is ending. The fabulous foursome, John Lennon, Paul McCartney, George Harrison, and Ringo Starr have simply let it be known that they are evolving in different directions.
They will reunite for the occasional recording, and there may even be a third film. But the grinding personal appearance tours, which are the basis of pop image building, are out. Beatlemania is at an end. Yet in a business where today's smash hit is tomorrow's stinker, the Beatles sound will almost certainly survive as the echo of an era. Their impact has been too great. Their public, from idolatrous teenagers to benignly approving intellectuals, is too universal, and their mythology too potent for forgetfulness. They have also produced music with some staying power. "When people ask to recreate the mood of the '60s," says Aaron Copeland, one of America's top serious composers, "they will play Beatles music."
Hounded for modestly accomplished working-class Liverpudlians, and their learner manager put such an indelible mark on the history of show business. It's almost exactly five years since Brian "Eppy" Epstein, the manager of a Liverpool record shop, signed a contract to manage a local popular, but nationally unknown beat group called the Beatles. In those days, they were all as green as one another.
Within two years, they became the biggest, most successful outfit by staying determinedly "unprofessional." The Beatles broke all the hollow codes of the pop world. They treated fans irreverently. They never donned gold lamé jackets, and most important of all, they declined to merge their identities behind a glamorized "lead" singer. Their method won on all levels. Pop fans were afforded a unique facility. They could be fickle in their affections to individual Beatles and still maintain allegiance to the group. In contrast with the Dave Clark Five. "If you go off Dave," said one DJ, "You're off the group."
At the upper end of the market, the newspapers were able to discover four pop stars, who could be frisky, witty, and occasionally wise-- a journalistic godsend. Yet even this combination seems inadequate to explain their meteoric success. By March 1964, with four Beatles records heading the U.S. charts, there were no more pop citadels to conquer. Epstein sticks to the line that they are "four wonderful boys with a talent that just had to break through," but Dick Lester, the balding, deeply switched-on American director, who so brilliantly bottled the Beatles' essence in a Hard Day's Night, feels the answer is more complex. "There were several Mersey groups back in the late 50s with the same basic background and the same scouse irreverence. They never made it."
Their being musicians at all was almost certainly an accidental product of being working class in one of the few British provincial cities with a vital teenage subculture; had they come from middle-class backgrounds, it is difficult to imagine any of them, with the possible exception of McCartney, as a musician. Lennon, for instance, might have made a competent advertising copywriter with a book going on the side, Harrison, a good medium-weight business executive, and Starr, the office clown.
The theory of four unique talents meeting by accident is patently absurd. Starr is clearly a nice bloke with one of those accidental personalities made to project itself, and he is probably one of the most moderate professional drummers in Britain. Harrison is the best instrumentalist of the four, and a passable guitarist, say among the best 1000 in the country. McCartney and Lennon are reasonably good amateur composers, greatly assisted by the poverty of British pop composing standards.
Alone it is difficult to imagine them getting anywhere, and they have had the sense to see this. In other words, this is a rare team in which the whole is really much more than the sum of the parts.
It is one reason why some serious students of pop take refuge in mysticism when seeking to explain the Beatles' appeal. Mike Raven, a rhythm and blues DJ, sees them as something like "the medieval concept of man, with John as the body, earth, Paul as the animal and the spirit, their totality." To secularize it, none of them could individually approach the Sinatra class as singers, but then Sinatra cannot write his own songs. Most of the 118 Beatles tracks were composed by Lennon and McCartney. Ray Charles is a considerable composer-singer, but had a somewhat spiky character. Boyishness takes the edge off the most classic Beatles songs. The Rolling Stones compose and sing and have youth on their side, but they seem angry about something. The Beatles have a happy charisma. "As I get older," said Paul, "I get more optimistic."
But as they have gotten older, the most appealing Beatles characteristic, exuberance, has inevitably weakened, and the fundamental honesty of their presentation has made them disinclined to manufacture a synthetic enthusiasm. The group's self-awareness has enabled them to realize before the fans and perhaps Epstein himself that the old game is up.
This awareness is no accident. It proceeds directly from a group situation in which four intelligent people carry roughly enough weight. It may be possible to fool one Beatles some of the time...
But collective self-delusion is nearly impossible. In a sense, the very best of the Beatles' music expressed sheer delight in being a tightly knit group of attractive young up-and-comers. Maturity, the waning of their collective narcissism, and the development of separate interests were bound to kill this phenomenon. For some time now, the Beatles' intellectual interests, all but Ringo, are dedicated self-improvers, have tended to diverge. Lennon's writing obsession is becoming more pronounced. "He is moving from Bob Dylan to Dylan Thomas," says Lester. Harrison has developed a groping interest in Eastern culture. The sitar, an Indian string instrument, has already infiltrated Beatles' recordings. Starr wants to act on his own.
Even the Lennon-McCartney nexus, the real core of the group, is splitting into two different musical directions. Lennon is clearly trying to create an unsentimental verbal style, while McCartney still uses a lot of saccharine in the lyrics and is more concerned with the melodic line.
And there have been emerging social divisions. Paul has not gotten married. Ringo and George are still observed by the nouveau riche stage, flashy cars and houses, whereas Paul and John are through it.
Epstein seemed somewhat more reluctant than the Beatles to recognize this centrifugal process. He admitted reluctantly that touring has become irksome. "Look at the debacle in Manila," but was not making any firm predictions. But the Beatles themselves are increasingly asking to be judged as individuals. It could be painful, but it is undoubtedly the adult thing to do.
Article directly below this one on the newspaper page:
M Beatles Plan Movie
by Rutgers
A new movie is being planned for the pop singing Beatles, and shooting may start by the end of January, their manager Brian Epstein said Tuesday. He emphatically denied rumors that the quartet may be breaking up, saying "There is nothing happening and no breakup."

No comments:
Post a Comment